Hydrology Research Publication Partnerships

  • Previous Article
  • Next Article

INTRODUCTION

Study area and data, results and discussion, conclusions, author contributions, data availability statement, conflict of interest, comparative analysis and risk assessment of dam-break floods: taking pingshuijiang reservoir as an example.

ORCID logo

  • Article contents
  • Figures & tables
  • Supplementary Data
  • Open the PDF for in another window
  • Guest Access
  • Cite Icon Cite
  • Permissions
  • Search Site

Xun Jiang , Jie Meng , Bingjie Fan , Chongxu Zhao , Yanshuang Zheng , Qianlu Xiao , Chunjin Zhang , Dongfang Ma; Comparative analysis and risk assessment of dam-break floods: Taking Pingshuijiang Reservoir as an example. Hydrology Research 1 February 2023; 54 (2): 265–275. doi: https://doi.org/10.2166/nh.2023.129

Download citation file:

  • Ris (Zotero)
  • Reference Manager

Due to the huge potential energy associated with water storage in reservoirs, dam-break floods are often catastrophically destructive for people and structures downstream. This study aims to simulate and compare floods generated under various dam-break scenarios and their downstream impacts, taking Pingshuijiang Reservoir in southeastern China as an example. A two-dimensional hydrodynamic model is used to simulate the downstream evolution of floods under three dam-break scenarios, and the breach flood and downstream inundation process are analyzed. Gradual failure of the main dam leads to near-total inundation of the nearby town over c. 1 h, allowing time for warning and evacuation. Instantaneous failure of the main dam results in larger peak flow, greater submergence depth and faster inundation (20 min), leaving little time for warning/evacuation. Instantaneous failure of the auxiliary dam generates a much lower peak flow magnitude and, although the town is still largely submerged within 45 min, the shallow water depth and low velocity are conducive to rescue/evacuation. The results show significant variation in flood process and submergence due to dam size and failure mode that provide guidance for dam-break flood risk assessment and disaster avoidance planning.

Simulate and compare floods generated under various dam-break scenarios and their downstream impacts.

The results will provide guidance for dam-break flood risk assessment and disaster avoidance planning.

Graphical Abstract

Graphical Abstract

Construction of reservoir dams and other water conservancy projects can deliver many social and economic benefits, such as flood control, power generation, irrigation, water supply, fishery, tourism, etc. ( Safarzadeh 2017 ; Guo et al. 2019 ; Khoshkonesh et al. 2022 ). However, the huge potential energy generated by flood storage also poses a great threat to the safety of life and property of people living downstream ( Xu et al. 2021 ). In recent years, the increased frequency of extreme climate phenomena ( Alcayna et al. 2022 ) has put the reservoir flood control standards calculated and formulated using existing hydrological data under scrutiny ( Chen & Sun 2021 ). Climate extremes also lead to the operation of reservoir dams under adverse conditions for a longer time, which directly affects the stability of the dam structure and accelerates ageing of hydraulic materials ( Cai et al. 2011 ), enhancing the dam-break potential.

Evidence from historical dam-break events in various countries highlights the potential for catastrophic damage to downstream people and properties ( Qiu et al. 2021 ; Seiya et al. 2021 ). One of the most significant dam-break events in China was on 8 August 1975, the collapse of the Banqiao Reservoir dam in western Henan province due to extreme rainfall generated by a tropical cyclone. The resulting floods affected 11 million people across 29 counties, with more than 26,000 deaths, 5.96 million houses destroyed, 11,300 km 2 of farmland inundated, 302,300 livestock lost and 102 km of the Beijing-Guangzhou railway destroyed; direct economic losses of nearly 10 billion yuan were recorded ( Bai & Zhen 2014 ). The Banqiao event involved a complete dam collapse, but even partial collapses can have devastating impacts due to chain effects. On 19 May 2020, the flood wave generated by the partial failure of the Edenville dam in Michigan in the United States led to overtopping of the Sanford dam and Poseyville embankment downstream, resulting in more than 10,000 people having to evacuate their homes and damage to more than 2,000 homes, as well as multiple roads, bridges and businesses ( Pradel & Lobbestael 2021 ).

Dam failure is mostly caused by floodwater infiltration, overtopping, material instability or external damage. The dam failure process may be gradual or instantaneous; the nature of dam failure (partial or complete, gradual or instantaneous) influences the flood process and downstream impacts. Instantaneous failures are often associated with catastrophic downstream impacts, such as the 1959 dam-break dam-break at Malpasset in France ( Duffaut & Larouzée 2019 ) and the 2011 Fujinuma dam-break in Japan ( Pradel et al. 2017 ). Systematic analysis of different dam-break modes requires the determination of flood parameters such as peak flow, time to peak, velocity and area of inundation.

Numerous approaches to modeling dam-break flood parameters and risk have been published in recent years. Delenne et al. (2012) assessed the potential of local sensitivity analysis for the analysis of uncertainty with respect to flash flood and dam failure risks in river hydrodynamics. Seyedashraf et al. (2018) used a method based on computational intelligence systems to simulate the classical one-dimensional dam-break flow problem that addresses the shortcomings of existing analytical and numerical models. Tedla et al. (2021) used hourly hydrological and meteorological data as well as high-resolution land surface datasets to simulate design floods for piping dam failure with empirical dam breach methods. With the requirements of decision makers for high-precision flood prediction, identification of flood-prone areas, flood inundation mapping and inundation assessment, GIS, high-definition remote sensing images, high-precision digital elevation model (DEM), MIKE software and The Hydrologic Engineering Center – River Analysis System (HEC-RAS) have gradually been added to dam-break numerical modeling ( Alvarez et al. 2017 ; Mao et al. 2017 ; Enea et al. 2018 ; Tamm & Tamm 2020 ; Mudashiru et al. 2021 ). A recent example is the work of Li et al. (2021) who used high-precision topographic mapping and DEM of the area around Qianping Reservoir in Ruyang County, Henan Province, China as the basis for one- and two-dimensional coupled dam-break numerical models using Geographic Information System (GIS) technology and MIKE software. Li et al. (2021) simulated the dam-break and flood discharge process under the 5000-year check flood level, calculated the flow process of the reservoir dam-break and the downstream evolution of the flood, obtaining flood risk information such as submerged area and flow patterns. Weilian et al. (2021) revealed the deficiencies of the existing systems for the floods simulation: the input data parameters are complex and the simulation process is cumbersome and time consuming. Then they developed a platform for the rapid 3D reproduction of dam-break floods which supports rapid reproduction at different times and positions. Based on Monte Carlo Simulation (MCS), HEC-RAS 2D, and HEC-LifeSim models, EL Bilali Ali et al. (2022) proposed an integrated approach on dam-break simulation, which can deal with the flood risk with probability rather than analyzing a few dam-break scenarios.

Most existing research focuses on a single dam-break scenario, and there is a lack of comparative analysis of flood process and downstream impact under different dam-break scenarios. Given the numerous potential causes of dam failure, there is potential for great differences in flood flow and downstream evolution with different dam-break scenarios. Single-scene dam-break flood analysis cannot fully meet the needs of practical applications; it is important to study the flood propagation process and downstream effects under various dam-break scenarios. This study explores the flood discharge and evolution process under three typical dam-break scenarios. Characteristic parameters such as breach flow, outflow time, time to peak, submerged range, flood velocity and flood arrival time are compared and analyzed for each scenario, and the disaster implications for downstream peoples and the structures are evaluated. The results are of significance for reservoir management departments to formulate flood control emergency plans, analyze flood risks and provide decision support for emergency agencies. The work also has reference value for government to improve regional flood control and disaster reduction capabilities and to enhance people's awareness of risk avoidance.

Location of Pingshuijiang Reservoir, southeastern China, showing topography of downstream area.

Location of Pingshuijiang Reservoir, southeastern China, showing topography of downstream area.

Relationship between Pingshuijiang Reservoir and Pingshui Town, Yuecheng District.

Relationship between Pingshuijiang Reservoir and Pingshui Town, Yuecheng District.

Pingshuijiang is a medium-sized reservoir with comprehensive functions of flood control, irrigation, water supply and power generation. The dam site is about 20 km from Shaoxing City, along the main stem of the Pingshui River. The river is a mountain system, with short and scattered tributaries. Floods are mainly generated by typhoon rainstorms and plum rain, which rise and fall rapidly and generally last for about 3 days. For dam-break floods, the potential area influenced downstream is about 357 km 2 , including Pingshui Town and Yuecheng District. The northern part of the reservoir is adjacent to Pingshui Town, which is in a basin and is surrounded by mountains. If a dam-break occurs, flood waters can only be discharged through the Kuaijishan gorge in the northern part of the town, and are directed to the Jishan Street area of Yuecheng District. This kind of reservoir is common in the economically developed areas of the Yangtze River Delta. It is of great significance to study the dam-break flood of this kind of reservoir for the safety risk analysis of the whole Yangtze River Delta region.

Characteristics of Pingshuijiang Reservoir

A dam-break flood model was constructed to determine the breach flood process and downstream evolution of the flood wave. The model has two elements: the breach flow process and the flood routing process.

Considering the most unfavorable situation where the breach develops vertically to the bottom of the dam and develops at a uniform speed, the longitudinal development process of the breach can be obtained by analogy using Equation (1).

For flood routing, the MIKE21 two-dimensional hydrodynamic calculation model was used to simulate the flood evolution and inundation process downstream of the reservoir. The model generalizes the flood-affected area, using a triangular mesh as the basis for simulation. As Pingshui Town as the key research object, the mesh was encrypted. The 357 km 2 area was divided into 69,253 grids cells, with terrain data use to assign the grid elevation. The upper boundary of the model was set at Pingshuijiang dam site or the auxiliary dam site, according to the scheme chosen for simulation. The lower boundary was set using closed features such as Shaozhu Expressway, Cao ‘e River and Sanjiang River. The calculation time step was set as 1 min, and the flood routing process was determined over 36 h.

Scenario setting

Gradual collapse of the main dam. As the water gradually rises to the design flood level during the event, water penetrates and erodes the main dam, resulting in its gradual collapse. This generates a large discharge flood in a short time. The upper boundary of the model is set as the breach flow process at the main dam site.

Instantaneous complete collapse of the main dam. This scenario considers the case where the reservoir is at the design flood level and is affected by strong destructive factors, such as earthquake activity or war, so that the main dam fails instantaneously. This results in a huge discharge flood in a very short time. The upper boundary of the model is set as the breach flow process at the main dam site. Due to the rapidity, there is no need to consider the breach development process in this scenario. The average width of the dam is 230 m, and the flow process after dam-break can be calculated directly using Equations (4) and (5).

Instantaneous complete collapse of auxiliary dam. This scenario considers the case where the water level is at the design flood level, but there is continued rainfall that may lead to flooding, so the auxiliary dam is artificially blown up to speed up flood discharge and ensure the safety of the main reservoir. This results in a small discharge flood in a very short time. The upper boundary of the model is set as the breach flow process at the auxiliary dam site. The average width of the auxiliary dam breach is 74 m.

Scenarios used in dam-break modeling

Dam-break discharge process

Discharge and water level process for dam-break. (a) Scenario 1; (b) Scenario 2; (c) Scenario 3.

Discharge and water level process for dam-break. (a) Scenario 1; (b) Scenario 2; (c) Scenario 3.

In Scenario 2, flood discharge peaks in the initial stage at 29,632 m 3 /s, with a spillway discharge of 485 m 3 /s ( Figure 3(b) ). The huge flow magnitude causes the reservoir water level to drop rapidly so that 10 min after the dam-break, water level is lower than the elevation of the spillway, and flood discharge from the spillway ceases. After about 30 min, discharge is around 9,000 m 3 /s and then gradually decreases to 111 min when the event is essentially completed.

Under Scenario 3, all floodwater is dumped at the auxiliary dam and discharge peaks at 2,589 m 3 /s at the initial stage ( Figure 3(c) ). Due to the relatively small discharge, flood duration is significantly longer (780 min), and the final reservoir water level is maintained at 38.7 m, which is the bottom elevation of the auxiliary dam.

Flood characteristics of each dam-break scenario (see Table 2 for details of scenarios)

Comparison of water level and discharge process for the modeled dam-break scenarios. (a) Water level; (b) Discharge.

Comparison of water level and discharge process for the modeled dam-break scenarios. (a) Water level; (b) Discharge.

Flood duration in Scenarios 1, 2 and 3 is 249, 111 and 780 min, respectively. The longest flood duration is associated with instantaneous failure of the auxiliary dam (Scenario 3), which is 3.1 times that of Scenario 1 and 7 times that of Scenario 2. The main reason for this is the relatively small breach of the auxiliary dam, which allows only small volumes of outflow and the flood takes longer to be fully discharged.

Flood impact analysis

Flood impact under the modeled dam-break scenarios

See Table 2 for details of each scenario

Submerged range and water depth

Modeled maximum submerged area and water depth in each dam-break scenario. (a) Scenario 1; (b) Scenario 2; (c) Scenario 3.

Modeled maximum submerged area and water depth in each dam-break scenario. (a) Scenario 1; (b) Scenario 2; (c) Scenario 3.

Submergence area for the modeled dam-break of each scenarios. (a) Maximum submergence area. (b) Submergence area 1 h after dam-break.

Submergence area for the modeled dam-break of each scenarios. (a) Maximum submergence area. (b) Submergence area 1 h after dam-break.

Submergence process

Changes in submergence depth over time under the modeled dam-break scenarios. (a) Pingshui Street, Pingshui Town; (b) Jishan Street, Langgang New Village.

Changes in submergence depth over time under the modeled dam-break scenarios. (a) Pingshui Street, Pingshui Town; (b) Jishan Street, Langgang New Village.

Figure 7(b) shows changes in submergence depth over time at Jishan Street, Langgang New Village. Here, flooding commenced at 150, 90 and 200 min after dam-break in Scenarios 1–3, respectively. The maximum submerged range was reached after about 10, 8 and 11 h, respectively.

Scenario 1 involves the gradual failure of the main dam. Though peak discharge reaches 11,440 m 3 /s, which almost submerges the whole of Pingshui Town, and has a direct impact on most township streets in Yuecheng District. However, flooding occurs gradually, and submerged water depth is largely below 1 m within 30 min of dam-break, and it takes another 30 min to submerge the main area of the town. Hence, there is sufficient time to warn and evacuate people living in the affected areas.

Scenario 2 involves the instantaneous complete collapse of the main dam. Peak discharge is significantly larger than in the other scenarios (30,117 m 3 /s), and occurs at the beginning of the dam-break. The flood reaches Pingshui Town after 7 min and the town is submerged within 20 min. The rapidity and extent of flooding would have a devastating effect on the whole town, with no time for early warning and immediate rescue/evacuation.

In Scenario 3, instantaneous failure of the auxiliary dam, peak discharge is much lower at 2,589 m 3 /s due to the relatively small breach and low rate of flow. Although the flood reaches the town in 12 min and submerges the town after 45 min, the water depth is generally less than 2 m. Hence, there is ample opportunity for rescue and evacuation.

There are two shortcomings to the study that could be addressed in future work. Due to the uncertainty of upstream rainfall conditions, inflow to the reservoir during dam-break is not considered. In addition, to fully consider the impact of the most unfavorable dam-break condition, the main dam instantaneous collapse scenario was adopted; however, this scenario is extremely rare for large and medium-sized earth-rock dams.

X.J. conceptualized the whole article; X.J. and C.Z. developed the methodology; X.J. and J.M. wrote the original draft; C.Z. and Q.X. conducted funding acquisition; J.M. and X.J. performed the investigation; X.J. and B.F. conducted data curation; C.Z. and D.M. visualized the article; Y.Z., Q.X. and C.J.Z. wrote the original draft and the review, and edited the article. All authors have read and agreed to the published version of the manuscript.

This study was sponsored by the Science and Technology Development Foundation of Yellow River Institute of Hydraulic Research (Grant No. HKF202202), the National Natural Science Foundation of China (Grant Nos. U2243220, 51909100 and 52009047) and the Fundamental Research Funds for the Central Scientific Research Institute (Grant No. HKY-JBYW-2020-03).

All relevant data are included in the paper or its Supplementary Information.

The authors declare there is no conflict.

Hydrology Research Metrics

Affiliations

Hydrology Research Publication Partnerships

  • ISSN 1998-9563 EISSN 2224-7955
  • Open Access
  • Collections
  • Subscriptions
  • Subscribe to Open
  • Editorial Services
  • Rights and Permissions
  • Sign Up for Our Mailing List
  • IWA Publishing
  • Republic – Export Building, Units 1.04 & 1.05
  • 1 Clove Crescent
  • London, E14 2BA, UK
  • Telephone:  +44 208 054 8208
  • Fax:  +44 207 654 5555
  • IWAPublishing.com
  • IWA-network.org
  • IWA-connect.org
  • Cookie Policy
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Get Adobe Acrobat Reader
  • ©Copyright 2021 IWA Publishing

This Feature Is Available To Subscribers Only

Sign In or Create an Account

  • Reference Manager
  • Simple TEXT file

People also looked at

Original research article, simulation of one-dimensional dam-break flood routing based on hec-ras.

www.frontiersin.org

  • 1 Key Laboratory of Disaster Prevention and Structural Safety of Ministry of Education, College of Architecture and Civil Engineering, Guangxi University, Nanning, China
  • 2 Guangxi Key Laboratory of Disaster Prevention and Engineering Safety, College of Civil Engineering and Architecture, Guangxi University, Nanning, China
  • 3 Guangxi Hydraulic Research Institute, Nanning, China
  • 4 School of Water Conservancy and Civil Engineering, Northeast Agricultural University, Harbin, China

Dam-break is a serious disaster resulting in severe damage to downstream communities. Therefore, analyzing the affected range and the evolution process of dam-break floods in advance is valuable. However, the difficulties and challenges lie in the complexity of the breaking process of earth-rock dams, the uncertainty in the evolution of dam-break floods, and the geographical variability. Given this, the objective of this study is to analyze the characteristics of the dam-break flood evolution. The study chooses Chengbi River Reservoir as the research object, HEC-RAS as the simulation software, unsteady flow differential equations and one-dimensional Saint-Venant equations as the control equations, and it uses four-point implicit finite difference method for discrete solution. In this paper, the dam-break flood evolution is simulated under three boundary conditions (full breach, 1/2 breach, 1/3 breach), and the main results are as follows. From the dam site section to the Tianzhou hy-drological station section, the peak discharge decay rates of the three schemes are 78%, 77%, and 67%, respectively. The water level decay rates of the three schemes are 47%, 36%, and 30%, respectively. A 1 m increase in the bursting water level elevation increases the peak flow by ap-proximately 7%, and the highest water level in front of the dam by 1 m, and delays the peak time by 1.5 h on average. In addition, the preliminary inundation extent for the Baise City is obtained. The analysis results can provide a fundamental basis for flood control as well as a reference for flood disaster management.

1 Introduction

Dam-break floods are serious disaster, and the damage they cause is much greater than that caused by a general floods ( Marangoz and Anilan, 2021 ). Flood dam is a dam to store floodwaters temporarily or to supply a surge of water. Once the dam break, it will bring unpredictable losses to people’s lives and properties downstream ( Luo et al., 2020 ). To reduce the losses caused by dam-break floods, many researchers have carried out simulations to predict the extent of their impact and the damage they cause. Bharath et al. (2021) used HEC-RAS to generate an inundation map and to identify the areas affected. The method they used is a modern computer-based flood numerical simulation method that is more accurate and faster than traditional methods. Currently, the study on numerical simulated of flood evolution is a hot topic, and a variety of research methods are applied to it. For instance, the MIKE 11 model was used to determine the inundation range of floods ( Nirwansyah and Braun, 2019 ; Jacob et al., 2020 ). The SWAT model was used to calculate flood runoff coefficients and combined with the GCM to create predictive assessments of flood hazards ( Toosi et al., 2020 ). Liu and Liu (2011) used the finite volume method to create a one- and two-dimensional dam-break numerical model for simulating the dam-break water movement process under ideal conditions. HEC-RAS, LISFLOOD, and TELEMAC_2D were used to simulate the flood inundation of a 60-km channel in the Severn River, United Kingdom, and the results showed that HEC-RAS and TELEMAC_2D can better predict the inundation area ( Horritt and Bates, 2002 ).

At present, the commonly used flood simulation software include MIKE, SWAT, HEC-RAS, and Xinanjiang model. ( Yu et al., 2018 ; Yao et al., 2019 ; Tansar et al., 2020 ). Compared with other hydraulic software, HEC-RAS has a user-friendly interface, good software compatibility, and it facilitates the calculation of various hydraulic structures. Among which the most representative one, the HEC-GeoRAS plug-in, can be combined with ArcGIS to extract topographic data in areas without measured data and provide river geometry data for hydrodynamic simulation ( Mokhtar et al., 2018 ; Raslan et al., 2020 ; Namara et al., 2021 ); therefore, the HEC-RAS model is selected for this study. One-dimensional or two-dimensional hydraulic models can be created in HEC-RAS ( Lea et al., 2019 ). Many studies have used the one-dimensional HEC-RAS simulation method. For example, Jung and Kim (2017) compared the results of one-dimensional HEC-RAS simulation with the data obtained by unmanned aerial vehicles and inferred the submerged area and depth distribution of floods. Butt et al. (2013) used a one-dimensional HEC-RAS model to estimate the potential disasters caused by dam failure under different peak conditions. Bellos et al. (2020) studied the uncertainty of dam failure parameters by using a one-dimensional HEC-RAS dam failure model. Similarly, in this study, a one-dimensional model is chosen because, compared to a two-dimensional model, it gives good results in cases of flood propagation along the main river ( Huanu et al., 2020 ), and takes less time to compute, which is more suitable for quickly responding to unexpected extreme events and achieving real-time assessments of risk ( Kaya et al., 2017 ; Lea et al., 2019 ).

In conclusion, although many studies have obtained results by using HEC-RAS models to simulate dam-break floods, there are still some problems to be solved, and the major difficulties are as follows: ① The process of earth-rock dam collapse is extremely complex, and different forms of dam failure have different effects on flooding; therefore, a certain degree of simplification for the dam breach morphology is needed ( Fu et al., 2018 ; Su et al., 2020 ). ② The dam-break flood is characterized by high peaks and waves, fast flow velocities, etc. When a dam-break flood evolves downstream, different failure modes will have different effects, which, combined with accuracy and errors challenges, make the evolution process of a dam-break flood highly uncertain ( Zhou et al., 2014 ; Abdedou et al., 2020 ; Kalinina et al., 2020 ; Ge et al., 2021 ). ③ Geographical variability is also a major element affecting flood simulation ( Sholtes et al., 2018 ).

To investigate the hydraulic characteristics of the dam failure flood under different dam-break conditions, the following framework is construed. ① The HEC-RAS (5.0.7) dam failure model is used to simulate the earth and rock dam failure process under various schemes and then analyze the effect of the failure model on the resulting flow process and water level process. ② A one-dimensional HEC-RAS (5.0.7) model is used to simulate the evolution of the dam failure flood with the boundary conditions of the breach flow process line for the three schemes; that is, full breach, 1/2 breach, and 1/3 breach, and then analyze its hydraulic characteristics and inundation extent of the evolution process.

The main contributions of this study are to analyze the effects of the duration time of dam break and the elevation of the bursting water level on the water level and discharge at the dam site, and to analyze the change in its hydraulic characteristics with the increase of the dam-break flood mileage. In addition, a preliminary inundation extent map for Baise City is obtained. The research results can have a guiding effect on the prevention of dam-break floods.

2 Materials and methods

2.1 study site.

Historically, rainfall in Baise is most concentrated in the summer. The city has two large reservoirs, the Chengbi River Reservoir and the Baise Reservoir, both of which have multiyear regulation functions. Heavy rainfall is prone to flash floods, destroying fields, houses, and water conservancy facilities. On 24 June 1967, the precipitation was 244 mm, resulting in 26,200 flooded acres, 24 flooded villages, and 4 deaths. In 1968, the waterlogged area was 0.78 million acres, leading to the loss of 362,500 kg of grain, six houses collapsed, five lives, and 17 water conservancy projects ( Liao et al., 2005 ). On 21 September 2015, the dike in Wangdian Township, Baise City collapsed due to heavy rain, flooding 300 acres of fertile land and affecting nearly 200 affected farmers.

Chengbi River Reservoir is located on Chengbi River, a tributary of the Youjiang River in northern Baise City, Guangxi. The reservoir is the most representative earth-rock dam in Guangxi and is only 10 km away from the urban area of Baise City and therefore would cause much damage to it if breached ( Mo et al., 2021 ). This large water conservancy hub project integrates irrigation, water supply, flood control and tourism. The main dam is an earth and stone dam with a concrete core wall and clay core wall, a crest elevation of 190.40 m, a maximum dam height of 70.4 m, a crest length of 425.0 m and a crest width of 10.0 m. The dam is equipped with a wave wall with a crest elevation of 191.80 m. The average multiyear flow rate of the dam site section is 37.8 m 3 /s and the average multi-year runoff is 1.192 billion m 3 . The design flood standard is 1,000 years flood design, 10,000 years flood check, and 1,121 million m 3 total storage capacity. In this study, Chengbi River Reservoir is the object of study, and Youjiang District and Tianyang County of Baise City are selected as its scope; the area has many karst landforms, sinkholes, skylights, and peak clusters. The approximate location of the study area is shown in Figure 1 .

www.frontiersin.org

FIGURE 1 . Geographical location of the study area.

In summary, the Chengbi River Basin was selected as the target watershed for this study because of its importance, typicality, and data feasibility. First, the city of Baise, located in the lower reaches of the Chengbi River basin, has high population density and economic development potential ( Ma and Luo, 2018 ). Second, few studies have examined the evolution characteristics of dam-break floods in the Chengbi River Basin. Finally, the Chengbi River Basin has a sufficient size and detailed hydrometeorological observations to meet the needs of this study ( Du et al., 2018 ).

The data used in this study mainly include topographic data and hydrological data. Topographic data are downloaded from the Geospatial Data Cloud [ http://www.gscloud.cn/ . (accessed on 7 January 2020)], provided by CNIC (Computer Network Information Center), and mainly include the DEM (Digital Elevation Model) for the study area. The data were collected from 2016 at a resolution of 30 m. The hydrological data come from the observation data of Chengbi River Reservoir BaShou station and mainly include the water level ∼ reservoir capacity relationship and the 10,000-year check flood hydrograph.

2.2 Methodology

2.2.1 sensitivity analysis.

The dam-break duration time is an important parameter for determining the characteristics of dam breaks. For parametric dam-break models, the duration time of dam-break needs to be determined from dam data and sensitivity analyses need to be performed. The Chengbi River dam was considered a total or partial breach, in order to analyze the sensitivity of dam-break peak discharge at the dam site and its downstream evolution process to the dam-break duration, nine schemes are set for the dam-break duration of overtopping: 2 h, 4 h, 6 h, 7 h, 8 h, 9 h, 10 h, 12 h and 24 h.

The dam-break duration time and the bursting water level elevation are the primary factors affecting the flow process and the flood peak of the breach, so sensitivity analysis was carried out on these two parameters by setting up different schemes to explore the extent of their influence on the flow process and the flood peak of the breach.

2.2.2 Constructing a dam-break model

The HEC-RAS dam-break model can simulate two modes of dam failure with overtopping and piping, and the breach flow is adopted from the broad top weir formula. Since most dam failures are due to overtopping ( Middlebrooks, 1953 ; Xie and Sun, 2009 ), this study assumes the dam failure to be an overtopping dam break. Based on the shape of the breached dams, the paper sets the shape of the dam break as an trapezoid. To discuss the influence of different dam-break sizes on the discharge process and flood peak, three different dam-break sizes are set: full breach, 1/2 breach, and 1/3 breach. The characteristic parameters of the dam (crest elevation, dam-break height, reservoir capacity, etc. ) are input into the HEC-RAS model, and the regression equation provided by HEC-RAS is applied to predict the final shape of the dam break.

In this study, nine different dam-break duration schemes and three kinds of water level elevations of dam breaks are proposed, and their influences on the discharge process and peak discharge of the dam site are analyzed. Specific data of each scheme are shown in Table 1 . The upstream boundary of all programs uses the Chengbi River Reservoir 10,000-year check flood hydrograph, and the downstream boundary uses the normal water depth (river slope drop) of 2.38‰ (the average slope drop of Chengbi River); the initial condition dam front water level is 189.29 m of the check flood level. The research results of breaches can also provide upper boundary conditions for flood routing model.

www.frontiersin.org

TABLE 1 . Chengbi River Reservoir dam-break scheme design.

2.2.3 Constructing a one-dimensional flood model

Principle of the one-dimensional hec-ras model.

The one-dimensional HEC-RAS model uses unsteady flow differential equations and control equations as a set of one-dimensional Saint-Venant equations, namely, the continuity equation and the momentum equation ( Brunner, 2010 ).

Data gathering

Since the study area has only 7 km of measured topographic data, the measured information is insufficient. Therefore, the study is mainly based on the downloaded DEM data ASTER GDEM V2 version and uses the projection coordinates of WGS 1984. The HEC-GeoRAS plug-in combined with GIS was used to extract the geometric data required for the simulation and to modify and improve it with the measured terrain data. The specific steps of HEC-GeoRAS to extract the river geometric data are as follows:

First, Google Earth was used to determine the location of the geometric data, including the river shoreline, floodplain boundary line, reservoirs, and bridges, and then cross-sections were created at 1 km intervals with additional sections at 200 m for river bends, for a total of 145 sections. Last, the results of the preprocessed geometric data were imported into the HEC-RAS model, and by interpolation, sections were created at 200 m intervals for a total of 500 sections.

Constructing model

The hydrological data mainly contain water level, flow data, flow characteristics information, and boundary conditions. The flow data provide information on the boundary conditions and peak flow composition of the study area when constructing the model. The HEC-RAS model can simulate three flow regimes: slow flow, rapid flow, and mixed flow. The boundary condition is one of the necessary conditions for constructing the numerical model, and it varies with the simulated flow states. For unsteady flow simulation, the hydrological and hydraulic information includes initial conditions and boundary conditions information.

This study focuses on the characteristics of the Chengbi River Reservoir breach flood and its impact on downstream areas. According to the flood characteristics and basic information of the study area, when setting the boundary conditions, the upstream boundary condition of the model adopts the time-flow hydrograph, and the downstream boundary condition of the model adopts the normal water depth. In addition, the 10-year discharge of the Baise hydropower junction should be superimposed for analysis and research. According to previous studies ( Xu et al., 2012 ), the final breach bottom width has a relatively small effect on the peak flow at the dam site, so this paper intends to set three kinds of breach final bottom elevations to analyze their effects on the flow process and peak flow at the dam site. Specific data of each scheme are shown in Table 2 .

www.frontiersin.org

TABLE 2 . Basic information sheet of each program.

Setting of parameters

(1) selection of river roughness.

Roughness is a parameter used to characterise the extent to which the roughness of the lower bedding wall affects the flow of water and is the most important parameter affecting the results of numerical flood simulations and hydrological analysis. Based on the downloaded 30 m resolution land cover information, HEC-GeoRAS was used to extract the section roughness as the initial value. To ensure that the section roughness value matches the actual one as far as possible, this paper used the flood results of the Baise hydropower junction, Chengbi River reservoir and the section below the Chengbi River estuary corresponding to the 1% frequency design peak flow of Baise Hydrological Station as the boundary conditions. Subsequently, HEC-RAS one-dimensional constant flow was used to determine the roughness rate of the river in combination with the water level, the discharge rate and the river characteristics at the hydrological station. The integrated roughness of the river channel is determined to be 0.045–0.06.

(2) Initial conditions

The multiyear average flow rate of the Chengbi River Reservoir is 37.8 m 3 /s, and the multiyear average flow rate of the middle reaches of the Youjiang River is 277 m 3 /s. The multiyear average flow rate of the two rivers is selected as the initial conditions of the model.

(3) Time step

The time step is an important condition affecting the model operation. Based on the convergence of the simulation results and the computational efficiency of the computer, the calculation time step is 1 min, and the output step of the hydrological process line is 10 min.

3.1 Dam-break model

The analysis of breach flow characteristics is the primary focus of dam-break floods. Additionally, analysing the maximum flow evolution process of dam-break floods is important for flood control planning and engineering design and construction in urban areas downstream of reservoirs. Breach flow is one characteristic that reflects the immense destructiveness of dam-break floods. The breach duration and initiation elevation are the main factors affecting the breach flow process and flood peaks. Therefore, sensitivity analysis of parameters is carried out by setting different schemes to explore the influence of these parameters on the process of dam-break flow and flood peak. The HEC-RAS dam-break model was used to simulate nine dam-break schemes to obtain the breach flow hydrograph, water level hydrograph and flood peak flow information.

3.1.1 Impacts of duration time on dam break

As shown in Figure 2A , the shape of the breach flow hydrograph is similar to that of the check flood hydrograph in all nine schemes, and two peaks appear. The main peak flow differs greatly for different dam-break duration but the second peak is basically the same. The crash starts to occur after 300 min (5 h) of simulation. As the incoming water from upstream continues to increase, the breach flow increases rapidly to the peak flow, then subsides rapidly to a certain flow, and then subsides again after slowly increasing to the second peak, eventually converging to baseflow. As the dam breach period increases, the breach flow hydrograph becomes flatter. From Figure 2B , within 8 h, the longer the dam-break time is, the smaller the peak flow at the dam site, the later the peak is, the flatter the breach flow hydrograph is, and the greater the impact of the dam-break time on the breach flow process. From Figure 2C , it is known that after the dam breach period exceeds 8 h, the change in the hydrograph of the breach flow is not significant with the increase in the breach period, and there is no longer a significant relationship between the peak present time and the breach period; it basically appears after the water level reaches the dam crest elevation for 5 h. Overall, the longer the formation time of the breach, the later the peak appearance time, but when the breach formation time exceeded a certain time (8 h), the peak appearance time is advanced.

www.frontiersin.org

FIGURE 2 . Discharge hydrograph of the dam break.

Figure 3 shows that the pre-dam level increases slowly and then decreases rapidly for all nine schemes, eventually levelling off with small fluctuations at approximately 167 m. The shorter the dam-break duration time is, the faster the pre-dam level decreases, but the change is not particularly significant, unlike the breach flow process, where there is a distinct time node (8 h) in the dam-break duration time that leads to a significant change in the pre-dam level process. This indicates that the dam-break duration has a small effect on the pre-dam level process.

www.frontiersin.org

FIGURE 3 . Hydrograph of the water level in front of the dam.

As seen in Table 3 , the peak flow rate of all nine schemes is greater than the peak flow rate of the check flood, which is 8,160 m 3 /s. The peak flow rate of the dam breach for Scheme 3 is 31,044 m 3 /s, which is 3.8 times the check peak flow; the peak flow rate of Scheme 4 is 23,033 m 3 /s, which is 2.82 times the peak flow rate of the check flood, and the peak flow rate of scheme 5 is 17,353 m 3 /s, which is 2.12 times the peak flow rate of the check flood. With the increase in the dam breach duration, the peak flow at the breach decreases, and the peak discharge of Scheme 3 is twice as high as that of scheme 11. Within 8 h, the peak flow decreases by 26% when the duration of the breach is increased by a factor of 3 (based on 2 h); over 8 h, the peak flow decreases by 17% when the duration of the breach is increased by a factor of 3 (based on 2 h). The decline rate of peak discharge decreased by approximately 8%, which indicates that the weakening effect on the peak flow decreases when the duration of the breach increases beyond a certain range. Up to 8 h, the peak present time increases with the increase in the dam-break period and occurs at the final formation of the breach; after 8 h, the peak present time no longer increases with the increase in the dam-break period and always occurs approximately 10 h after the start of the simulation. This indicates that the peak present time no longer varies with the duration of the breach when it is beyond a certain range.

www.frontiersin.org

TABLE 3 . Information on the peak discharge of the dam-break.

3.1.2 Impacts of elevation on bursting water level

Figure 4A shows that the shape of the route flow hydrograph is similar for the three schemes and similar to the check flood hydrograph; all of them have two peaks, and the main peak will increase due to the increase in the initiation elevation, while the second peak is not affected. The lower the bursting water level elevation is, the earlier the breach flow is generated and the earlier the flow drops after peaking, and the breach flow eventually tends to baseflow. This indicates that the bursting water level elevation has little influence on the flow process of the breach. As seen in Figure 4B , the shape of the pre-dam water level hydrograph is similar for all three schemes; it rises slowly to the crest elevation, continues to rise to the highest water level, falls off quickly to a certain level, then rises slightly to the next peak level, and finally stays near the final bottom elevation of the breach at 167 m with small fluctuations. The greater the elevation of the bursting water level is, the greater the highest water level in front of the dam; however, the difference is small. This indicates that the influence of the bursting elevation on the water level process in front of the dam is relatively small.

www.frontiersin.org

FIGURE 4 . (A) Discharge hydrograph of dam break (B) Process line of the water level in front of the dam.

As shown in Table 4 , the peak flow at the breach increases with increasing breach elevation, and the corresponding water level and the maximum water level in front of the dam increases as well. When the bursting elevation is 190.4 m, the peak flow at the breach is 31,044 m 3 /s; when the bursting elevation exceeds 191.4 m, the peak flow at the breach is 33,147 m 3 /s; and when the bursting water level elevation exceeds 192.4 m, the peak flow at the breach is 33,995 m 3 /s. A 1 m increase in bursting elevation increases the peak flow by 7%–2,103 m 3 /s and by 10%–2,954 m 3 /s for a 2 m increase in the bursting elevation. This indicates that the elevation of the bursting water level has a relatively small effect on the peak flow and pre-dam level and a large effect on the peak present time.

www.frontiersin.org

TABLE 4 . Information on the peak discharge of the dam break.

3.2 One-dimensional flood model

Dam-break floods are characterized by large peaks and fast flow velocities. When a dam-break flood evolves downstream, different modes of the dam break will have different impacts. The key protection targets in the Chengbi River Reservoir are Baise City (10 km downstream), villages, buildings, roads, and farmland along the river downstream. In this section, nine representative sections downstream of the dam site (including the dam site section) are selected to analyze the dam-break flood characteristics of different schemes.

3.2.1 Flow processes at characteristic cross-sections of different schemes

Based on the HEC-RAS 1D simulation results and the characteristics of the study area, nine characteristic sections were selected for analysis, and the flow hydrographs of the characteristic sections for each scheme were obtained as shown in Figure 5 below. The along-range peak flow table of the dam-break flood is shown in Table 5 , and the along-range trend of the peak flow for each scheme shown in Figure 6 was obtained.

www.frontiersin.org

FIGURE 5 . Discharge hydrograph of all program characteristic sections.

www.frontiersin.org

TABLE 5 . Maximum flood peak flow along the dam breach.

www.frontiersin.org

FIGURE 6 . Trend of maximum peak flow along the path.

It can be seen from Figures 5A–C and Table 5 that under full breach conditions (Scheme 1), the discharge at the dam site rapidly rises to the peak discharge of 3,35,693 m 3 /s, oscillates slightly near the peak, and then decreases rapidly. There are eight characteristic sections downstream of the dam site, namely Baise Hydrological Station, Longwang Bridge, Dahe Village, Suwu, Baifeng Village, Liwu and Napo and the peak discharge decreases along the way. When reaching the section of Tianzhou Hydrological Station 73.4 km downstream of the dam site, the peak discharge decayed to 73,411 m 3 /s, with a decay rate of 78%, but far exceeded the check flood discharge of 8,160 m 3 /s. Under the condition of 1/2 dam failure (Scheme 2), the flood peak flow at the dam site rises rapidly to 60,540 m 3 /s, oscillates slightly near the peak value, and then decreases rapidly, reaching the section of Tianzhou Hydrological Station 73.4 km downstream of the dam site, and the flood peak flow attenuates to 12,194 m 3 /s, with an attenuation rate of 77%, still far exceeding the check flood discharge of 8,160 m 3 /s. Under the condition of 1/3 dam failure (Scheme 3, the dam failure lasted 2 h), the dam site flow rapidly rises to the peak flow of 31,044 m 3 /s, oscillates slightly near the peak value, and then decreases rapidly, reaching the section of Tianzhou Hydrological Station 73.4 km downstream of the dam site, and the peak flow attenuates to 10,075 m 3 /s with an attenuation rate of 67%.

Figure 6 shows that the slope of the peak flow variation curve becomes larger as it approaches the dam site. The slopes of the three schemes are 18,944.52, 1,259.84, and 693.49 in the vicinity of the dam site (12.6 km ahead), while the slopes of the three schemes are 278.81, 346.14, and 129.03 in the downstream area, far from the dam site (27 km–74.2 km away from the dam site). It can be seen that the flood peak flow rate of each scheme decreases along the course, and the closer it gets to the dam site, the more rapidly it decreases. By comparing schemes 1, 2, and 3, it is found that the flood peak flow rate at the dam site decreases as the flood evolves downstream.

In summary, with the increase in flood routing mileage, the peak flow process becomes flatter, and the peak flow decreases along the way. For dam failures of the same duration, as the degree of dam failure increases, the peak discharge of dam failure becomes greater, and the attenuation rate of the corresponding dam failure flood increases. For the same degrees but different durations of dam breaks, the peak discharge decays more slowly downstream, but the difference in peak discharge decreases when the distance is within a certain range.

3.2.2 Water level process in characteristic sections of different schemes

The dam-break flood level is an important indicator of downstream inundation severity. Results of the one-dimensional simulation for the water level process, maximum water level variation trend, and maximum flood level characteristic table of each scheme are sorted as follows.

From Figures 7A–C and Table 6 , show that the water level process of all three schemes becomes increasingly flat along the course. Under full breach conditions (Scheme 1), the water level at the dam site rises rapidly to a maximum level of 257.75 m and then decreases rapidly. At a total of eight characteristic cross-sections downstream of the dam site, including the Baise hydrological station, Longwang Bridge, Dahe Village, Suya, Baifeng Village, Liya, Napo Town and the Tianzhou hydrological station, the flood water level decreases sequentially along the course and decays to 137.2 m when it reaches the cross-section of the Tianzhou hydrological station 73.4 km downstream of the dam site, with an attenuation rate of 47%. Under the 1/2 breach condition (Scheme 2), the water level at the dam site rises rapidly to 189.78 m, oscillates slightly near the peak, and then decreases rapidly to 121.76 m 3 /s at the Tianzhou hydrological station 73.4 km downstream of the dam site and has a decay rate of 36%. Under the 1/3 breach condition (Scheme 3), the flow at the dam site rises rapidly to a water level of 173.61 m, oscillates slightly near the peak, and then decreases rapidly to reach the Tianzhou hydrological station section 73.4 km downstream of the dam site, where the water level decays to 120.79 m and has a decay rate of 30%.

www.frontiersin.org

FIGURE 7 . The stage hydrograph of all program characteristic sections.

www.frontiersin.org

TABLE 6 . Maximum water level change along the dam breach.

Figure 8 shows that the slope of the maximum water level change curve increases as it approaches the dam site. The slopes of the three schemes are 7.20, 3.56, and 2.65 in the vicinity of the dam site (12.6 km before), while the slopes of the three schemes are 0.56, 0.44, and 0.38 in the downstream area, far from the dam site (27 km–74.2 km from the dam site). The highest water level of the dam failure flood decreases along the course, and the closer to the dam site, the more rapid the decay becomes. Comparing schemes 1, 2, and 3, it is found that with the same dam failure duration time and different degrees of dam failure, the larger the water level at the dam site is, the higher the decay rate, and as the flood evolves downstream, the difference in water level between different schemes decreases, but there is still a large gap.

www.frontiersin.org

FIGURE 8 . Trend of the maximum stage along the path.

In summary, with the increase in flood routing mileage, the flood water level process becomes flatter, and the water level decreases along the way. For the same duration of the dam break, with the increase in the dam break degree, the higher the dam break water level is, the higher the corresponding dam break flood attenuation rate.

3.2.3 Flood inundation range and water depth

Through one-dimensional dam-break flood routing simulations, the flood routing of different schemes is obtained. In reality, following its third reinforcement, the Chengbi River Reservoir dam became an earth-rock dam with mixed concrete and clay core walls; now, the probability of total failure is smaller, while the probability of 1/2 and 1/3 failure is larger. Therefore, using Scheme 2 and Scheme 3 as examples, this study analyzes the characteristics of the inundation range and depth of the dam-break flood. The maximum inundation range and depth distribution of the two schemes are shown in Figure 9 .

www.frontiersin.org

FIGURE 9 . (A,B) Dam-break flood submerging range of Scheme 2, (C,D) Dam-break flood submerging range of Scheme 3.

As seen in Figures 9A,C , within the simulation range, the inundation ranges of the two schemes are basically the same from the dam site to 10 km downstream of the city of Baise; however, the inundation depth increases with the increase in dam-break flood inflow, i.e., the inundation depth of Scheme 2 is greater than that of Scheme 3. The inundation situation of the two schemes is similar; that is, the river section from the Chengbi River Reservoir dam site to the Youjiang River estuary is mostly mountainous terrain, and the dam-break flood basically flows within the river channel (elevations on both sides of the river are above 170 m). After reaching the urban area of Baise City, the terrain is open and flat, and a large number of floods flow to the shore for lateral movement (elevations on both sides of the river range between 125 m and 135 m). As the river flows to the vicinity of Jiulai Village on the border of Youjiang District and Tianyang County, the terrain again changes to mountainous landforms, and the flood basically flows in the river channel (elevations on both sides of the river are above 130 m). When it reaches the vicinity of Nameng Village and the terrain once again changes into an open small plain, the flood progresses to the riverbank again (elevations on both sides of the river range between 110 m and 115 m). The flood discharged from the Baise hydropower junction reaches the vicinity of the Bailin Bridge from the dam site, is relatively steep with a slope of 10.6‱, and almost unaffected by the dam-break flood of the Chengbi River, which basically flows in the river channel; on the other hand, due to the relatively flat topography of urban areas in Baise City and the large discharge and rapid flow of dam-break floods in the Chengbi River, the dam-break peak flows backward into the Paoai River, superposing the floodwater from the upstream Baise Reservoir and flowing towards the shore together, thus flooding both banks on a large scale.

4 Discussion

The effect of the dam breach shape on downstream flood processes examined in a previous study ( Xu et al., 2012 ) showed that the influence of the dam site shape on downstream flood processes decreases as the distance of downstream flood evolution increases, and eventually several flow curves almost coincide at 120 km from the breach. However, the results in this study are slightly different. Although Scheme 2 and 3 have similar flow rates at 80 km downstream, Scheme 1 has a flow rate nearly four times larger than the other schemes. Under normal conditions, the bottom elevation of the breached dam, as well as the width of the bottom, will have an effect on the flow of the breached flood; the lower the bottom elevation and the wider the width, the larger the downstream flow will be. One reason for this difference is that the flow is much more affected by the depth than by the width to which it is subjected, and Scheme 1 has the lowest bottom dam elevation; thus, it is most affected. In addition, the selected cross-section is still too close to the breach, at 80 km, which is not enough to counteract the effects of the huge breach in Scheme 1, so the water flow is still affected by the shape of the breach. Moreover, the existence of flood storage and detention areas can have a slight impact on downstream flows ( Li et al., 2008 ). Where large amounts of floodwater enter the downstream area of the Chengbi River Reservoir, the terrain on both sides of the river is open and flat, which greatly improves flood storage capabilities. Only when the dam-break flood reaches a certain scale and exceeds the regional impoundment capacity will the flood have a significant downstream impact.

The one-dimensional HEC-RAS model has good feedback for flood evolution simulation of long river channels in mountainous areas, but there are still shortcomings for flood evolution simulation in flat and open areas. As shown in Figures 9B,D , within the urban area of Baise City, almost all of the breach flood reaches the cross-sectional boundary line in the one-dimensional model for horizontal movement. Therefore, within the urban area of Baise City, the evolution of the dam-break flood cannot be characterized by using only the one-dimensional model simulation. Simulation using a two-dimensional model is required to calculate the inundation of different dam failure floods schemes in the urban area of Baise City. In future studies, the damage to the urban area can be investigated using two-dimensional simulations.

At present, most of the research results on dam-break flood simulation focus on the downstream inundation extent, but less on the hydraulic characteristics of the dam-break flood. In addition, few studies that have examined dam-break flood characteristics have focused only on non-karst areas rather than karst areas ( Yang et al., 2018 ). As one of the most vulnerable landform types in the world, karst landscapes are highly sensitive to environmental changes. With the change of climate and the growing economic development of Baise city, it is of certain research significance to simulate the dam failure of Chengbi River Reservoir. In this study, Chengbi River Reservoir is chosen as the research object and simulated by HEC-RAS to analyze not only the possible inundation range downstream but also the detailed hydraulic characteristics of dam-break floods.

However, some shortcomings remain. 1) Dam-break floods carry large amounts of sediment. Although the impact of these sediments on the simulation may be relatively small and limited, from a scientific point of view, relevant information should be collected and added to the simulation model in the future to match the actual conditions as closely as possible. 2) Due to the complexity of the breaching mechanism, a dam breach simulation study based on only three set scenarios: full breach, 1/2 breach, and 1/3 breach, cannot reflect the full picture of the breach evolution and flooding process at the dam site. The study of earth and rock dam breach evolution and real-time dynamics of the flooding process will be enhanced in the future.

5 Conclusion

Understanding the characteristics of dam-break flood is important for the formulation of flood control plans and the construction of flood mitigation projects in downstream areas. Therefore, the HEC-RAS hydrodynamic model is used to simulate the flood evolution process in this study. The main conclusions are as follows.

(1) The longer the duration of the breach, the flatter the process of breach flow, the smaller the peak flow, and the later the peak present time. 8 h is a demarcation point for the duration of the Chengbi River Reservoir breach.

(2) The effect of the bursting water level elevation on the process of breach flow and the water level in front of the dam is relatively small. A 1 m increase in the bursting water level elevation increases the peak flow by approximately 7% and the highest water level in front of the dam by 1 m; the effect of the bursting water level elevation on the peak present time is larger, and the peak time is delayed by 1.5 h on average for every 1 m increase.

(3) For the same dam failure duration time, as the dam failure degree increases, the peak flow of the dam failure flood becomes higher and the corresponding dam failure flood attenuation rate rises. From the dam site section to the Tianzhou hydrological station, the attenuation rates of Scheme 1, Scheme 2, and Scheme 3 are 78%, 77%, 67%, respectively.

(4) For the same dam-break duration, with the increase in the dam-break degree, the higher the dam-break water level is, the higher the corresponding breach flood attenuation rate. From the dam site section to the Tianzhou hydrological station, the attenuation rates of Scheme 1, Scheme 2, and Scheme 3 are 47%, 36%, 30%, respectively.

These findings are very helpful to the downstream areas. In view of dam-break flood, the river section representing the dam site to Longwang Bridge has the most variable peak flow in all three schemes, indicating that the local government should pay attention to the maintenance and construction of embankments and flood control measures in this section. As seen from the flood inundation map, due to the sudden flat and open terrain, the flood broke away from the river channel and flooded both banks of Baise City and Nameng Village. Therefore, when a dam-break flood occurred, government agencies should evacuate the residents on both sides of the Chengbi River in these two areas. The study of the hydraulic characteristics of the dam failure flood in this paper can enable the government and related workers to activate their rescue and transfer center in the area with the greatest flood variation and reduce the allocation of rescue resources to downstream areas where the peak flow is stabilized, thereby protecting lives in the area downstream of the reservoir to the greatest extent. Data regarding the inundation range of Baise City shown by the one-dimensional model also can facilitate creating flood control and flood risk maps for Baise City to some extent, as well as support the rapid formulation of transfer plans to provide a basis for executing correct and efficient flood control decisions.

These findings can also be used for reference in the study of dam-break flow characteristics in other watersheds. Based on these findings, further research is needed. For example, analyzing the inundation area of the city by using two-dimensional HEC-RAS model. Furthermore, the dam-break flood risk assessment can be carried out in key areas.

Data availability statement

The original contributions presented in the study are included in the article/supplementary material, further inquiries can be directed to the corresponding author.

Author contributions

Conceptualization, CM, YS, XL, and YR; methodology, YS, XL, and HB; software, HB; validation, formal analysis and investigation, CM, YS and YR; resources, CM; data curation, WC; writing—original draft preparation, YS and HB; writing—review and editing, XL, YR and SL; supervision, YR; project administration, CM; funding acquisition, CM, YR and ZX All authors have read and agreed to the published version of the manuscript.

This research was funded by the National Natural Science Foundation of China (Grant No. 51969004), the Interdisciplinary Scientific Research Foundation of GuangXi University (Grant No. 2022JCC028), and the National Natural Science Foundation of China (51979038).

Conflict of interest

The authors declare that the research was conducted in the absence of any commercial or financial relationships that could be construed as a potential conflict of interest.

Publisher’s note

All claims expressed in this article are solely those of the authors and do not necessarily represent those of their affiliated organizations, or those of the publisher, the editors and the reviewers. Any product that may be evaluated in this article, or claim that may be made by its manufacturer, is not guaranteed or endorsed by the publisher.

Abdedou, A., Soulamani, A., and Tchamen, G. W. (2020). Uncertainty propagation of dam break flow using the stochastic non-intrusive B-splines Bézier elements-based method. J. Hydrology 590, 125342. doi:10.1016/j.jhydrol.2020.125342

CrossRef Full Text | Google Scholar

Bellos, V., Tsakiris, V. K., Kopsiaftis, G., and Tsakiris, G. (2020). Propagating dam breach parametric uncertainty in a river reach using the HEC-RAS software. Hydrology 7, 72. doi:10.3390/hydrology7040072

Bharath, A., Shivapur, A. V., Hiremath, C. G., and Maddamsetty, R. (2021). Dam break analysis using HEC-RAS and HEC-GeoRAS: A case study of hidkal dam, Karnataka state, India. Environ. Challenges 5, 100401. doi:10.1016/j.envc.2021.100401

Brunner, G. W. (2010). “HEC-RAS (river analysis system),” in North American water & environment congress & destructive water . New York: Hydrologic Engineering Center of US Army Corps of Engineers .

Google Scholar

Butt, M. J., Umar, M., and Qamar, R. (2013). Landslide dam and subsequent dam-break flood estimation using HEC-RAS model in Northern Pakistan. Nat. Hazards (Dordr). 65, 241–254. doi:10.1007/s11069-012-0361-8

Du, Y., Ma, R., and Zhao, L. (2018). Research on annual runoff prediction of Chengbihe River based on EEMD-BP-ANN model. Guangxi Water Resour. Hydropower Eng. 2018 (2), 11–14. doi:10.16014/j.cnki.1003-1510.2018.02.004

Fu, X., Gu, C. S., Su, H. Z., and Qin, X. N. (2018). Risk analysis of earth-rock dam failures based on fuzzy event tree method. Int. J. Environ. Res. Public Health 15, 886. doi:10.3390/ijerph15050886

PubMed Abstract | CrossRef Full Text | Google Scholar

Ge, W., Wang, X., Li, Z., Zhang, H., Gelder, P. H. A. J. M. V., Wang, T., et al. (2021). Interval analysis of the loss of life caused by dam failure. J. Water Resour. Plan. Manag. 147, 04020098. doi:10.1061/(asce)wr.1943-5452.0001311

Horritt, M. S., and Bates, P. D. (2002). Evaluation of 1D and 2D numerical models for predicting river flood inundation. J. Hydrology 268, 87–99. doi:10.1016/s0022-1694(02)00121-x

Huanu, E., Mihu-Pintilie, A., Urzica, A., Paveluc, L. E., and Grozavu, A. (2020). Using 1D HEC-RAS modeling and LiDAR data to improve flood hazard maps' accuracy: A case study from jijia floodplain (ne Romania). Water 12, 1624. doi:10.3390/w12061624

Jacob, X. K., Bisht, D. S., Chatterjee, C., and Raghuwanshi, N. S. (2020). Hydrodynamic modeling for flood hazard assessment in a data scarce region: A case study of bharathapuzha River basin. Environ. Model. Assess. (Dordr). 25, 97–114. doi:10.1007/s10666-019-09664-y

Jung, C. G., and Kim, S. J. (2017). Comparison of the damaged area caused by an agricultural dam-break flood wave using HEC-RAS and UAV surveying. Agric. Sci. 08, 1089–1104. doi:10.4236/as.2017.810079

Kalinina, A., Spada, M., Vetsch, D. F., Marelli, S., Sudret, B., Burgherr, P., et al. (2020). Metamodeling for uncertainty quantification of a flood wave model for concrete dam breaks. Energies 13, 3685. doi:10.3390/en13143685

Kaya, C. M., Tayfur, G., and Gungor, O. (2017). Predicting flood plain inundation for natural channels having no upstream gauged stations. J. Water & Clim. Change 10 (2), 360–372. doi:10.2166/wcc.2017.307

Lea, D., Yeonsu, K., and An, H. (2019). Case study of HEC-RAS 1D–2D coupling simulation: 2002 baeksan flood event in korea. Water 11, 2048. doi:10.3390/w11102048

Li, C., Huang, J., He, X., and Ma, X. (2008). Flood caused by dam failure of the Danjiangkou reservoir. J. Changsha Univ. Sci. Technol. Sci. 03, 1–7.

Liao, X. P., Hang, W. J., Shao-Long, L. U., and Quan, Y. S. (2005). Classification and genetic analysis of disaster flood in Baise City . Nanning: Gx Water Resources & Hydropower Engineering .

Liu, M. Q., and Liu, Y. L. (2011). Numerical simulation of 2D dam-break flow in a vertical plane. Appl. Mech. Mater. 130-134, 3620–3623. doi:10.4028/www.scientific.net/amm.130-134.3620

Luo, Y., Chen, X., and Yao, L. (2020). Flood disaster resilience evaluation of Chinese regions: Integrating the hesitant fuzzy linguistic term sets with prospect theory. Nat. Hazards (Dordr). 105, 667–690. doi:10.1007/s11069-020-04330-z

Ma, Y., and Luo, S. (2018). Analysis of the current situation of the tax source structure of the Baise economy and suggestions for optimization. Rev. Econ. Res. 47, 6. doi:10.16110/j.cnki.issn2095-3151.2018.47.009

Marangoz, H. O., and Anilan, T. (2021). Two-dimensional modeling of flood wave propagation in residential areas after a dam break with application of diffusive and dynamic wave approaches. Nat. Hazards (Dordr). 110, 429–449. doi:10.1007/s11069-021-04953-w

Middlebrooks, T. A. (1953). Earth-dam practice in the United States . New York: Transactions of the American Society of Civil Engineers .

Mo, C., Ruan, Y., Xiao, X., Lan, H., and Jin, J. (2021). Impact of climate change and human activities on the baseflow in a typical karst basin, Southwest China. Ecol. Indic. 126, 107628. doi:10.1016/j.ecolind.2021.107628

Mokhtar, E. S., Pradhan, B., Ghazali, A. H., and Shafri, H. (2018). Assessing flood inundation mapping through estimated discharge using GIS and HEC-RAS model. Arab. J. Geosci. 11, 682. doi:10.1007/s12517-018-4040-2

Namara, W. G., Damisse, T. A., and Tufa, F. G. (2021). Application of HEC-RAS and HEC-GeoRAS model for flood inundation mapping, the case of awash bello flood plain, upper awash River basin, oromiya regional state, Ethiopia. Model. Earth Syst. Environ. 8, 1449–1460. doi:10.1007/s40808-021-01166-9

Nirwansyah, A. W., and Braun, B. (2019). Mapping impact of tidal flooding on solar salt farming in northern java using a hydrodynamic model. ISPRS Int. J. Geoinf. 8, 451. doi:10.3390/ijgi8100451

Raslan, A. M., Riad, P. H., and Hagras, M. A. (2020). 1D hydraulic modelling of Bahr El-Baqar new channel for northwest Sinai reclamation project, Egypt. Ain Shams Eng. J. 11, 971–982. doi:10.1016/j.asej.2020.02.005

Sholtes, J. S., Bledsoe, B. P., Yochum, S. E., and Scott, J. A. (2018). Longitudinal variability of geomorphic response to floods. Earth Surf. Process. Landforms 43, 3099–3113. doi:10.1002/esp.4472

Su, H., Wen, Z., and Qian, C. (2020). Cellular automata-based analysis for seepage failure process of earth-rock dam. Struct. Control Health Monit. 27, e2553. doi:10.1002/stc.2553

Tansar, H., Babur, M., and Karnchanapaiboon, S. L. (2020). Flood inundation modeling and hazard assessment in Lower Ping River Basin using MIKE FLOOD. Arab. J. Geosci. 13, 934. doi:10.1007/s12517-020-05891-w

Toosi, A. S., Doulabian, S., Tousi, E. G., Calbimonte, G. H., and Alaghmand, S. (2020). Large-scale flood hazard assessment under climate change: A case study. Ecol. Eng. 147, 105765. doi:10.1016/j.ecoleng.2020.105765

Xie, J. B., and Sun, D. Y. (2009). Statistics of dam failures in China and analysis on failure causations. Water Resour. Hydropower Eng 40 (12), 124–128.

Xu, F., Zhou, H., Zhou, J., and Yang, X. (2012). A mathematical model for forecasting the dam-break flood routing process of a landslide dam. Math. Problems Eng. 2012, 16. doi:10.1155/2012/139642

Yang, S., Yang, W., Qin, S., Li, Q., and Yang, B. (2018). Numerical study on characteristics of dam-break wave. Ocean. Eng. 159, 358–371. doi:10.1016/j.oceaneng.2018.04.011

Yao, C., Ye, J., He, Z., Bastola, S., Zhang, K., and Li, Z. (2019). Evaluation of flood prediction capability of the distributed Grid-Xinanjiang model driven by weather research and forecasting precipitation. J. Flood Risk Manag. 12, 14. doi:10.1111/jfr3.12544

Yu, D., Xie, P., Dong, X., Hu, X., Liu, J., Li, Y., et al. (2018). Improvement of the SWAT model for event-based flood simulation on a sub-daily timescale. Hydrol. Earth Syst. Sci. 22, 5001–5019. doi:10.5194/hess-22-5001-2018

Zhou, Z., Wang, X., Sun, R., Ao, X., and Song, M. (2014). Study of the comprehensive risk analysis of dam-break flooding based on the numerical simulation of flood routing. Part II: Model application and results. Nat. Hazards (Dordr). 72, 675–700. doi:10.1007/s11069-013-1029-8

Keywords: dam-break flood, flood modeling, flood routing, HEC-RAS, water security, hydrograph

Citation: Mo C, Shen Y, Lei X, Ban H, Ruan Y, Lai S, Cen W and Xing Z (2023) Simulation of one-dimensional dam-break flood routing based on HEC-RAS. Front. Earth Sci. 10:1027788. doi: 10.3389/feart.2022.1027788

Received: 25 August 2022; Accepted: 30 September 2022; Published: 10 January 2023.

Reviewed by:

Copyright © 2023 Mo, Shen, Lei, Ban, Ruan, Lai, Cen and Xing. This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (CC BY). The use, distribution or reproduction in other forums is permitted, provided the original author(s) and the copyright owner(s) are credited and that the original publication in this journal is cited, in accordance with accepted academic practice. No use, distribution or reproduction is permitted which does not comply with these terms.

*Correspondence: Xingbi Lei, [email protected]

Dynamic behavior analysis of bridge pier under impact of dam-break flood in different directions

  • Original Paper
  • Published: 07 December 2023

Cite this article

  • Shuai Huang   ORCID: orcid.org/0000-0002-9081-2760 1 &
  • Chuanzheng Liu 1  

69 Accesses

Explore all metrics

The dam-break flood formed after the collapse of a dam due to factors like earthquakes and heavy rainfall poses a significant potential threat to the safe service of downstream bridge pier. To reveal the dynamic behavior of bridge pier under impact of dam-break flood, a calculation model for a bridge pier under the impact of dam-break flood was established based on the smoothed particle hydrodynamics (SPH) method. On this basis, dynamic response of wave pressure and wave force due to varying impact angles of the flood on the pier was explored. Results demonstrate that the wave pressure on the pier gradually weakens with the increase in the impact angle, and the flood exerts little influences on the pier when the angle exceeds 45°; wave pressure decreases more significantly at the bottom of the pier as the impact angle increases; the pier is sensitive to influences of initial water height, when the initial wave height remains unchanged, the floods exert gradually deceased influences on the pier with the dam-break flood height rising. Finally, the wave flume experiments were carried out to verify the accuracy and reasonability of our proposed SPH-based calculation model.

This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.

Access this article

Price includes VAT (Russian Federation)

Instant access to the full article PDF.

Rent this article via DeepDyve

Institutional subscriptions

research paper on dam break analysis

Amsden AA, Harlow FH (1970) A simplified MAC technique for incompressible fluid flow calculations physics. J Comput 6(2):322–325

Google Scholar  

Dogan K, Peter T (2012) Description of loading conditions due to violent wave impacts on a vertical structure with an overhanging horizontal cantilever slab. Coast Eng 60(1):201–226

Hong Z (2012) Study on the calculation theory of water damage resistance of highway bridges and culverts in Qinba mountain. Chang’an University, Xi’an

Huang S, Liu C (2022) A computational framework for fluid–structure interaction with applications on stability evaluation of breakwater under combined tsunami–earthquake activity. Comput‐Aided Civ Infrastruct Eng 38(3):325–352. https://doi.org/10.1111/mice.12880

Article   Google Scholar  

Iai S (1988) Similitude for shaking table test on soil-structure-fluid model in 1g gravitational field. Rep PHRI 27(3):1–24

Jiaheng Z, Yaozhe Z, Min Li (2013) Experimental study of piers scour in complex boundary condition. J Sediment Res 1:14–19

Jie L (2016) The numerical simulate of parallel double bridge piers impact by dam-break flood. Pearl River 37(8):6–9

Jinbao Y, He X, Jiawallg H (2010) Analysis on influence of the bridge foundation under scouring on natural vibration characteristics of pier. China Railw Sci 31(1):44–48

Jinkun H, Zhiwei L (2013) Protection of bridge scour using pile groups with porous basket. Chin J Geotech Eng 35(2):982–985

JTG D60–2015 (2015) General specifications for design of highway bridges and culverts

Kumar V, Raju KGR, Vittal N et al (1999) Reduction of Local scour around bridge piers using slots and collars. J Hydraul Eng 125(12):1302–1305

Linfeng H, Pingyi W, Huaihan L et al (2013) Analysis of spur dike reliability by the action of flood and evaluation of residual life. Hydro-Sci Eng 6:54–61

Monaghan JJ (1994) Simulating free surface flows with SPH. J Comput Phys 110:399–406

Peng S (2015) Study on safety of simply supported box girder bridge structure under the action of flood. Chongqing University, Chongqing

Shiyun X, Xiaoqing W (2010) Study on routing model and impact loading of flood. Eng Mech 27(9):35–42

Sumer BM, Whitehouse RJS (2001) Scour around coastal structures: a summary of recent research. Costal Eng 44(2):153–190

TB 10002.1–2005 (2005) Fundamental code for design on railway bridge and culvert

Wardhana K, Hadipriono FC (2003) Analysis of recent bridge failures in the United States. J Perform Constr Facil 17(3):144–150

Wen Yu, Xueli Ge, Lixin Z et al (2011) Simulated experimental study on model of buildings in mountain area under flow action. J Beijing Jiaotong Univ 35(1):24–29

Yang Lihong Wu, Guohui ZG (2010) Calibration of parameters in large strain constitutive model with logarithmic stress rate. Chin Quart Mech 31(1):71–75

Download references

This work is financially supported by research grants from the China Postdoctoral Science Foundation (2021M691391), the Open Foundation of the United Laboratory of Numerical Earthquake Forecasting (Grant No. 2021LNEF04).

Author information

Authors and affiliations.

Ministry of Emergency Management, National Institute of Natural Hazards, Beijing, 100085, China

Shuai Huang & Chuanzheng Liu

You can also search for this author in PubMed   Google Scholar

Corresponding author

Correspondence to Shuai Huang .

Ethics declarations

Conflict of interest.

The authors declare no conflict of interest.

Additional information

Publisher's note.

Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.

Rights and permissions

Springer Nature or its licensor (e.g. a society or other partner) holds exclusive rights to this article under a publishing agreement with the author(s) or other rightsholder(s); author self-archiving of the accepted manuscript version of this article is solely governed by the terms of such publishing agreement and applicable law.

Reprints and permissions

About this article

Huang, S., Liu, C. Dynamic behavior analysis of bridge pier under impact of dam-break flood in different directions. Nat Hazards (2023). https://doi.org/10.1007/s11069-023-06301-6

Download citation

Received : 07 April 2022

Accepted : 27 October 2023

Published : 07 December 2023

DOI : https://doi.org/10.1007/s11069-023-06301-6

Share this article

Anyone you share the following link with will be able to read this content:

Sorry, a shareable link is not currently available for this article.

Provided by the Springer Nature SharedIt content-sharing initiative

  • Dam-break flood
  • Smoothed particle hydrodynamics
  • Dynamic behavior
  • Wave flume experiment
  • Find a journal
  • Publish with us
  • Track your research

Academia.edu no longer supports Internet Explorer.

To browse Academia.edu and the wider internet faster and more securely, please take a few seconds to  upgrade your browser .

Enter the email address you signed up with and we'll email you a reset link.

  • We're Hiring!
  • Help Center

paper cover thumbnail

Dam Break Analysis -A Case Study

Profile image of Innovative Research Publications

This paper is mainly focused on the effects of post dam break. It can be estimated from the flood developed from the dam break. It will also throw light on high flood areas in the downstream side of the dam which will help assess the type of emergency facilities. Keywords: Dam-Break Analysis, Dam Breach, Dam CFD, Pawana Dam I. In tr oduct i on 1.1. Dam Break Analysis:-Dam break analysis is characterization and identifying of potential dam failures are post effects of resulting floods from dam breach. It is this characterization of the threat to public safety that a dam poses decides the classification of the dam and also the standard of care, safety and maintenance to which the dam is held. The requirement to prepare an emergency action plan, requiring preparation of inundation maps which accurately predict dam breach flood depths and arrival times at critical locations. The population associated along with the critical section are located in close proximity downstream of a dam, details of the breaching process and the calculated peak discharge may have little effect on the results. The breach parameters like breach width, depth, and rate of development are more crucial to analyse especially when the locations of population centres are near to the dam. The associated cost and assumptions increases if the breach parameters cannot be predicted with reasonable accuracy. A recent query of the dam safety engineers within the Colorado Dam Safety Branch determined that there is currently no consensus nor up-to-date guidance regarding the state-of-the-practice procedures for performing dam breach analysis.This study can also estimate high flood level and, to fix the flood control lines on downstream side of the dam, estimation of wave pressure after dam break. The study also focus on to understand the hydraulic characteristics and breach shape, understand the flow of huge debris from upstream as well as downstream which will be carried away with flow after dam break, study the erosionof dam after dam break, it give important information for embankment on the downstream sides of the river. It also helps to avoid erosion of soil along the embankment of downstream. 1.2. Need for Dam-Break Analysis:-Two major consequences of a bam failure are:-1. Life loss: This loss occurs if the villages and the residing families are washed away by the flood resulting from dam-break. 2. Economic:Economic loss is calculated in terms of revenue which will be required to rebuild the washed away villages in terms of infrastructure, and other allied facilities.

Related Papers

Shridhar Joshi

Dams are constructed to serve a variety of purposes such as supply of drinking and irrigation water, generation of electric power, flood protection etc… However a dam break may result in high flood waves traveling along a valley at quite high speed. The intensity of the catastrophic failure of dams varies depending on the extent of inundated area, size of the population under risk and the warning time available. The present study deals with the Dam Break Analysis of Thenmala Dam of Kerala State, India. As a part of the work, the maximum precipitation and maximum flood have been evaluated using the Gumbel's and Clark's method respectively. The final analysis is done using the software BOSS DAMBRK for evaluating the extent of inundation, travel time and velocity of downstream progressing water.

research paper on dam break analysis

IRJET Journal

Mullaperiyar Dam is one of the oldest and weakest dams which is on the verge of collapse. Failure of the dam will have a catastrophic effect on people and property downstream. Thus, Dam break analysis has become increasingly critical for enabling rigorous scientific inquiry and analysis into the eminent risk so that proper remedial measures can be taken. Our project aims at performing the dam break analysis of the Mullaperiyar dam and the following Idukki arch dam. The Idukki dam is the largest arch dam in Asia and has an enormously large capacity. If a dam break happens it will be heavily affected by the thickly populated state of Kerala, so it is necessary to do the flood hazard mapping of both the dam. The final product of our project is to construct a flood inundation map.

eSAT Journals

Water Science and Technology

SEZAR GÜLBAZ

The aim of this study is to analyze the effects of a possible dam failure under various scenarios and to generate a flood hazard map for two consecutive dams located in a study area with a dense-residential region and a heavy-traffic highway. Two consecutive dams consist of Elmalı 2, a concrete-buttress dam and Elmalı 1, an earth-fill gravity dam in the upstream and downstream, respectively. Hydrologic Engineering Center-River Analysis System (HEC-RAS) was used to develop a dam failure model. Dam failure scenarios were examined regarding three main criteria: the Breach Formation Time (BFT), the Number of Failed Buttresses (NFB) of Elmalı 2, and the Reservoir Volume Ratio (RVR) of Elmalı 1. Accordingly, flood peak depth (Hp), peak flow rate (Qp), peak velocity (vp), and time to reach the peak (tp) are discussed. The results showed that BFT and NFB of Elmalı 2 were highly effective on these values, whereas RVR of Elmalı 1 had no significant effect. Moreover, the total area affected by...

International Journal of Environmental Science & Technology

Puong Ling Law

Research Square (Research Square)

Nilanchal Patel

Journal of the Civil Engineering Forum

Maria Sumira

Sermo Dam is located in the Special Region of Yogyakarta and serves multiple purposes including providing drinking water, supplementing irrigation systems in the Kalibawang area, and flood control. According to data published by the World Commission, 60% of mitigation measures taken to overcome the impact of dam structure failures are unsuccessful. The simulation of dam failure serves as a crucial aspect of flood mitigation plans and strategies because it is more destructive than natural flood waves. This research used HEC-RAS 5.0.7 to examine the flood inundation mapping and simulate dam failure in two dimensions. However, Dam Break Analysis was adopted to provide a Dam Emergency Action Plan Guide to guide managers and the community. The overtopping scenario was adapted to model the failure of the Sermo Dam based on the frequent occurrence of heavy and extreme precipitation in the affected area. Data were analyzed using unsteady flow and PMF discharge with peak inflow discharge of ...

Journal of Hunan University Natural Sciences

Ery Suhartanto

This research intends to evaluate the risk-level change of dam break due to the number of population growth rates in the dam downstream. The number of population growth rates in the dam downstream area causes the number of populations that is impacted by disaster risk. In this research, there is conducted the danger class classification of dam failure based on the increasing number of population growth rates. In this research, there is conducted a class classification about the dam failure based on the increasing of population growth rate. The methodology is started from data collecting such as PMF design flood that is used for analyzing the dam break to be obtained the flood boundary of the dam downstream area, Map of the Digital Elevation Model that is for knowing the topography of the dam downstream area, population data which is obtained from BPS that is for knowing the population growth rate so it can predict the population number until the life time of the reservoir, and the l...

International Journal of Agriculture Innovations and Research

Shahram Mousavi

Dams are constructed for a specific purpose such as agricultural water supply, flood control, irrigation, navigation, sedimentation control, and hydropower. Using the most recent publication of the World Register of Dams, irrigation is by far the most common purpose of dams. Simulation of dam breach events and the resulting floods are crucial to characterize and reduce threats due to potential dam failures. The studies of dam breach are necessary and important in academic studies, the government's planning and investment in downstream of the dams. In this research, considering the importance of the dam breach studies and resulting flood routing, based on the previous studies, new equations were presented for estimating dam breach parameters (breach width, side slope, time of failure and peak outflow) by collected data from 142 broken dams. Dimensional analysis and multiple regression were used to predict maximum outflow from earth dam breach. The uncertainty of equations was eva...

Lariyah Mohd Sidek

Dams have long been acknowledged for providing electricity which is the form of renewable energy, for flood protection, and for making water available for agriculture and human needs. However, the huge amount of energy stored behind the dam results in serious danger to society in case of dam failure. When a dam is breached, catastrophic flooding will occur as the impounded water escapes through the breach and flows into the downstream valley which may cause great devastation in terms of lives lost as well as property damages. The main purpose of the study was to establish dam breach characteristics in prediction of Kenyir outflow hydrograph. Kenyir dam break modelling due to a breach were performed under two scenarios namely Probable Maximum Flood (PMF) scenario and Clear Day scenario. Froehlich and MacDonald & Langridge-Monopolis equations were used in the determination of the dam breach parameters. With the obtained outflow hydrograph, it is possible to see the negative effects by routing it at the downstream. MIKE 11, a very powerful and comprehensive one dimensional model was used. The hydrodynamic module solves the complete nonlinear St. Venant equations for open channel flow. Results obtained from the study indicated that PMF scenario yields higher peak discharge of 412,962 m 3 /s compared to the Clear Day scenario, 380,336 m 3 /s. The results are reliable since the breach outflow results vary between 24% and 25% for both scenarios compared using Froehlich peak discharge equations.

RELATED PAPERS

Computers & Fluids

Leevan Ling , Nicolas Ali Libre

Dhaka University Journal of Pharmaceutical Sciences

Golam Kibria

WFL Publisher Ltd

JFAE Journal Administration

Drug Metabolism Reviews

sonja nikolic

Cleber Bisognin

Benjamin Meier

European Journal of Scientific Research

Zakir Hussain

e usos de evidências no Brasil : conceitos, métodos, contextos e práticas

Vahíd Vahdat

European Journal of Organic Chemistry

Ajeet singh Ajeet singh

The Journal of Basic and Applied Zoology

Narayan Mane

Current Eye Research

Berthold Seitz

Journal of Internal medicine and emergency research

Journal of Internal Medicine and Emergency research

Alvina Vina

Ganesh Kumar

David W Jardine

Marine Ecology Progress Series

Megan Dethier

Andre Surendre

International Heart Journal

MEHMET BALLI

Jacek Wilczyński

María del Pilar Martín-Tamayo Blázquez

(In) Subordinações Contemporâneas: Linguística, Letras e Artes

Alejandra Escribano

Silvana Walter

JAMA Dermatology

Tianshuang Wu

Physical Review E

Giovanni Volpe

Russian Peasant Studies

Stephen Wegren

Journal of Cleaner Production

Elaine Fitches

Journal of the Science of Food and Agriculture

Cristina Marzo

RELATED TOPICS

  •   We're Hiring!
  •   Help Center
  • Find new research papers in:
  • Health Sciences
  • Earth Sciences
  • Cognitive Science
  • Mathematics
  • Computer Science
  • Academia ©2024

IMAGES

  1. (PDF) DAM BREAK ANALYSIS AND EMERGENCY PREPAREDNESS PLAN IN AREAS OF

    research paper on dam break analysis

  2. (PDF) Dam Break Analysis–A Case Study

    research paper on dam break analysis

  3. (PDF) Literature Review of Dam Break Studies and Inundation Mapping

    research paper on dam break analysis

  4. Dam Break Analysis Using Hec Ras A Case Study

    research paper on dam break analysis

  5. (PDF) Emergency action plans: Assessment of the main elements for dam

    research paper on dam break analysis

  6. (PDF) Dam break analysis for BRDA 5 at Worsley Alumina Refinery

    research paper on dam break analysis

VIDEO

  1. Receipt Paper Is Toxic

  2. 'Next Warren Buffett', 'Crypto King' Sam Bankman Faces 110 Years In Jail

  3. Engineering Hydrology 37

  4. Break pond dam 2

  5. The WORST dam break in history! #podcast #funny #weather

  6. Breaking The Dam

COMMENTS

  1. (PDF) Dam Break Analysis -Review of Literature

    ... The breaching process is very complex, so, it is very difficult to accurately predict the location, extend rate, and final final extent dimensions. Determining the consequences of dams...

  2. Dam break analysis using HEC-RAS and HEC-GeoRAS: A case study of Hidkal

    The immediate downstream of the dam experience a peak flow of 72,085.45 m /s and 78,454.82 m /s and the corresponding inundation area of 75.224 km due to piping failure and overtopping failure, respectively. Around twenty village located on the downstream of dam location gets affected due to flood produced by dam break.

  3. Two-Dimensional Modelling for Dam Break Analysis and Flood Hazard

    Feature papers represent the most advanced research with significant potential for high impact in the field. A Feature Paper should be a substantial original Article that involves several techniques or approaches, provides an outlook for future research directions and describes possible research applications. ... For dam break analysis caused ...

  4. Three-Dimensional Numerical Modelling of Real-Field Dam-Break Flows

    Numerical modelling is a valuable and effective tool for predicting the dynamics of the inundation caused by the failure of a dam or dyke, thereby assisting in mapping the areas potentially subject to flooding and evaluating the associated flood hazard. This paper systematically reviews literature studies adopting three-dimensional hydrodynamic models for the simulation of large-scale dam ...

  5. Water

    Interests: numerical and physical modeling of unsteady free surface flows; assessment of flood hazard due to levee breach or dam-break; mathematical modeling of mixed flows; analysis of seismic-induced flow motions; analysis of the performance of side weirs; analysis of spatially varied flows Prof. Dr. Gabriella Petaccia E-Mail Website Guest Editor

  6. Comparative analysis and risk assessment of dam-break floods: Taking

    Most existing research focuses on a single dam-break scenario, and there is a lack of comparative analysis of flood process and downstream impact under different dam-break scenarios. Given the numerous potential causes of dam failure, there is potential for great differences in flood flow and downstream evolution with different dam-break scenarios.

  7. Two-dimensional dam-break wave analysis: particle image velocimetry

    Dam-break waves have been the focus of a number of research papers; next to analytical investigations, scaled experimental models and numerical simulations are used to determine dam-break wave propagation. Experimental models and data analysis tools are necessary to generate calibration data for numerical models.

  8. Dam Break Analysis of Temenggor Dam Using HEC-RAS

    10.1088/1755-1315/479/1/012041 Dam Break Analysis of Salomekko Dam Using Zhong Xing HY21 Dam break analysis using 1D geometry at Jatigede Dam, Sumedang Comparison of hydrodynamic and sediment transport model for dam break analysis over mobile bed Shock wave propagation of circular dam break problems

  9. Statistical analysis methods for transient flows

    The dam-break flow, as an example of severe transient flow, is used in this paper as test case for the application of different statistical methods identified in the literature: the common statistical tools (e.g. time average, standard deviation), the application of a Fourier-series-based method and the ensemble statistics approach.

  10. Frontiers

    Dam-break is a serious disaster resulting in severe damage to downstream communities. Therefore, analyzing the affected range and the evolution process of dam-break floods in advance is valuable.

  11. VLVRI7HPHQJJRU'DP8VLQJ +(& 5$6 Zhehao Lin

    the unexpected event of dam break occurs. This paper discusses the dam break analysis of Temenggor Dam by evaluating the dam breach parameter of Temenggor Dam based on dam failure scenarios, analyzing breach hydrograph for 1-dimensional (1-D) and 2-dimensional (2-D) model and proposing inundation map using GIS. 2. Methodology

  12. PDF Characterizing the Dam Break Release Juliana Wu

    The failure of a dam can cause disastrous consequences, thus understanding the nature of a dam break is of utmost importance. A model of a dam break was built and used to profile the resulting wave. The gate release was characterized to check for consistency, maximum velocity, and it's profile. Matlab code was created to analyze both the gate

  13. Water

    This paper provides a review of the historical dam-break events for which real-field datasets useful for validation purposes can be retrieved in the literature. The resulting real-field test cases are divided into well-documented test cases, for which extensive and complete data are already available, and cases with partial or inaccurate datasets.

  14. PDF Dam-Break analysis: proposal of a simplified approach

    Dam-Break analysis: proposal of a simplified approach Análise de ruptura de barragens: proposta de uma abordagem simplificada Carlo Lucca Coutinho Ungaretti Rossi1 , Marcelo Giulian Marques1 , Eder Daniel Teixeira1 , José Falcão de Melo2 , Rute Ferla1 & Maurício Dai Prá1

  15. Dam Break Analysis: Importance, Methods, and Applications

    C. P. Kumar. Dam break analysis is a critical tool used to assess the potential consequences of a dam failure and to develop emergency plans to mitigate the risk. In this article, we discuss the importance of dam break analysis in dam safety management, emergency planning, and environmental impact assessment.

  16. Dynamic behavior analysis of bridge pier under impact of dam-break

    The dam-break flood formed after the collapse of a dam due to factors like earthquakes and heavy rainfall poses a significant potential threat to the safe service of downstream bridge pier. To reveal the dynamic behavior of bridge pier under impact of dam-break flood, a calculation model for a bridge pier under the impact of dam-break flood was established based on the smoothed particle ...

  17. Water

    Feature papers represent the most advanced research with significant potential for high impact in the field. ... Abderrahmane Boudoukha, Lahcen Benaabidate, and Haroun Chenchouni. 2022. "Modeling and Risk Analysis of Dam-Break Flooding in a Semi-Arid Montane Watershed: A Case Study of the Yabous Dam, Northeastern Algeria" Water 14, no. 5: 767 ...

  18. PDF Dam Break Analysis using HECRAS with DEM Generated Geometry

    The dam break analysis is done using HECRAS and HECGeoRAS software and the inundation map is prepared. The conclusions of the study are. The maximum probable precipitation is obtained as 388.272 mm (24 hours duration rainfall) The probable maximum flood is obtained as 2848.80 cumecs.

  19. Dam Break Analysis -A Case Study

    Dam Break Analysis:-Dam break analysis is characterization and identifying of potential dam failures are post effects of resulting floods from dam breach. It is this characterization of the threat to public safety that a dam poses decides the classification of the dam and also the standard of care, safety and maintenance to which the dam is held.